Network user ID issues



We have the following setup:

  • clojure collector on a domain that is different to our website
  • javascript tracker sending POST

We see that even if the user is browsing the same domain, for quite a large amount of sessions nuid is changing. I have seen an older thread (Oct 2016) about this happening due to 3rd party cookies being blocked etc. My question would be if there are any solutions of building “reliable” nuids in some non-conventional way? E.g. would mixing in GET requests and modelling data afterwards in Redshift lead somewhere? Any ideas are highly appreciated.



Hi @vytenisj,

This issue has nothing against HTTP method used. Some time ago browsers (first one was Safari) started to block 3rd party cookies and you can do nothing with it - you had to force users to change privacy settings, what is impossible.

Note, that browsers allow you to set 3rd party cookie if you have visited the site as 1st party and created a cookie. I have seen solutions with a kind of ping-pong, like user with no network_id cake is redirected to landing page, that sets network_id cookie and pings user back to referrer page. This works but is ugly. I am not sure if it is 100% legal. Note, that iframes do not work here - this have to be browser _top window…

Some time ago there were possible solutions with using Etag meta field, but this does not work (at least with Safari) no more. Moreover, using this or similar practises could make you pay lots of $$ for user privacy violation.

As far as I know, there is no easy, clean and legal solutions to track users between sites.


Thanks for the info @grzegorzewald , very helpful already!